Irish Sports News, Other Irish Sport
Controversial Officiating in BYU vs Arizona State
Published
The recent clash between BYU and Arizona State in Provo was overshadowed by a series of officiating controversies that have sparked debate over the interpretation of Big 12 rules. The game, which ended in a 27-20 victory for BYU, saw a contentious decision early on that set the tone for the match.
Controversial Call
During BYU’s opening drive, quarterback Bear Bachmeier fumbled the ball near the Arizona State goal line. Officials initially ruled that his forward progress had been stopped, ending the play. However, after a review, the ball was placed short of the end zone. A subsequent review credited running back Sione Moa with a touchdown for recovering the loose ball and reaching the end zone, giving BYU a 7-0 lead.
This decision was met with confusion, as it appeared to contradict the rules as understood by the FOX broadcast team. Rules analyst Mike Pereira noted that once a play is ruled dead, the ball can be awarded to the recovering player but cannot be advanced. Former NFL officiating head Terry McAulay echoed this sentiment, describing it as a significant error.
Pattern of Controversy
This incident is part of a broader pattern of officiating issues involving BYU games. Previous matches have seen missed calls and questionable penalties, leading to criticism from commentators and fans alike. Arizona State’s head coach, Kenny Dillingham, expressed his frustration on the sidelines, arguing that the whistle had blown.
Despite the setback, Arizona State mounted a comeback in the second half, led by freshman quarterback Jake Fette and running back Cardae Mack. However, their efforts fell short, and BYU secured the win, improving their record to 7-1 in the Big 12.
The ongoing controversies have prompted calls for the Big 12 to address the perceived inconsistencies in officiating, as fans and analysts continue to question the league’s handling of such situations.
FOLLOW IRISH DISTRICT
See More from Irish District on Google
Add Irish District as a Preferred Source to see more of our latest Irish sports, culture and community coverage across Google.
You can manage your preferred sources through your Google account at any time.Continue reading
Clare Fan’s Memorable Journey from Croke Park to Vienna
Donie Garrihy's passion for sport took him from Clare's All-Ireland win to supporting Ireland in Vienna.
Harry Kane Set for Record England Cap
Kane to become England's most-capped player against Croatia.
Derry’s All-Ireland Hopes Within Reach
Tony Scullion believes Derry can secure an All-Ireland title within five years, drawing on past successes and current...
